Hate crime legislation...?

[mrph]

As some of you will be aware, there's an online (UK) petition to broaden the definition of hate crimes in the wake of Sophie Lancaster's death.

Personally, I have to say that I'm unconvinced by the concept of hate crime laws. Not just in this case, but generally. On the other hand, I don't actually have any facts and figures about this to hand - it's just a vague unease.

I'm sure someone out there knows rather more than I do, though. So...

1. Are they effective when a case comes to court?
2. Do they actually make a difference as a deterrent?
3. Should two similar crimes be treated differently depending on what motivated them - should the courts treat a completely random attack differently from a hate crime...?

I know this is a very emotive subject - and I do want to see the people responsible for this sort of attack jailed for a very long time. But is this the best way to do that? Are the existing laws sufficient - or do they need strengthening in other ways...?

Comments

[missfairchild.livejournal.com]

What happened to Sophie Lancaster and her boyfriend was appalling and I hope that whoever was responsible is put away for a very, very long time.

But I'm not convinced that it was a "hate crime". They were walking through a park known as the haunt of violent gangs in the small hours of the morning. Chances are that anyone walking into the path of the gang would have been attacked whether they were goths, crusties, trendies or dressed head to foot in M&S machine-washable office wear.